Several months ago, when East Bridgewater High School Athletic
Director John Lucier was first suspended for unknown reasons,
Superintendent of Schools Margaret Strojny told the community she
couldn’t comment on an ongoing investigation, but said: “When the
investigation is completed there will be a resolution.” Lucier resigned
from the school, and everything changed.
The school dropped their investigation, and the next time we heard
about Lucier, it was from the police when he was charged with two
counts of providing alcohol to a minor, one of which occurred at East
Bridgewater High School.
Then, nothing. It certainly doesn’t feel like a resolution.
To be fair, this is a tricky situation for the schools, as it would
be for any employer. It’s a sticky legal situation, and we don’t
blame folks for being overly cautious in this litigious society.
But among the charges filed against Lucier is the allegation that he
gave alcohol to a student in his office, on school property. This
happened under the superintendent’s nose, and it needs to be addressed.
But it’s not just the official channels that are silent here. There
doesn’t seem to be a demand for answers from the residents and school
parents of East Bridgewater.
The lack of knowledge when a teacher leaves under a cloud of
suspicion is not a complaint unique to East Bridgewater. We’ve
been reading reports all over the state –– and indeed the
country –– about school teachers or coaches mysteriously leaving their
posts, and parents are left with unanswered questions. The only thing
the schools will ever say is a vague statement about “improper
conduct.” If no charges are filed in court, parents may never
know what happened.
This is a shame, and it’s something parents of school children
everywhere should be questioning. We trust teachers with our children
for eight hours a day. Although 99 percent of them deserve that trust,
when one does something wrong, we deserve to know the full truth.
In East Bridgewater, after Lucier’s arrest on charges of providing
alcohol to a minor, the response from the town has been silence. The
School Committee only mentioned the matter in the briefest of terms, to
accept Lucier’s resignation. It seems the community would rather
pretend this never happened. This does every student and parent of a
school-age child in town an injustice.
Parents should be asking the school what they knew, and when they
knew it. And the school should be telling parents why this won’t happen
again. Maybe the school district isn’t legally able to answer every
question in the minds of parents. But that doesn’t mean we
shouldn’t have the conversation.
Again, Lucier hasn’t been convicted of anything. He is innocent
until proven guilty in a court of law. But that doesn’t mean that East
Bridgewater, as a community, shouldn’t be having a dialogue about the
issue of what’s appropriate in the student/teacher
relationship. There’s only one way to make the problem
worse – ignoring it, and pretending nothing ever happened.